Research note

Chapter 4 ↔ Chapter 2 connection map

Map of where chapter 4 (“What’s in it?”) empirical paragraphs should be tied to chapter 2 (theory) literature.

INTRO #C8LCTY /#J84KVC: announce practice-as-entity (materials, meanings, competencies) frame from #7GWZ3Q flag movement between entity and performance #KZTSUL #VUVLX5

4.1 INCOMING FLOW #W24ZWB

  • #N3RJWV → practice bundles/complexes via Nicolini & Shove #45DCHA

  • #SR59ZR → Evans divestment vs disposal #KKUN6K Gregson/Hetherington on disposal as ordering #ERE9WJ Sigaard normalisation #LHDJD5

  • #4KXTYB → Evans detachment as relational; Sigaard identity-work in disposal

  • #AFHG64 → Miller, women as moral agents #N2ZBHC divestment as care for imagined other

  • #G4BQFM #Z4E96B → Beswick-Parsons et al. consumption work: decanting, stock management, recirculating #946W3P Schatzki site ontology bundle #VEYFQG

  • #CJVC7H /#MDLZYA/#8H9MU8 (pressure valve critique) → Hobson et al. unequal distribution of consumption work #T7N8QV Warde & Welch value-action gap #3R87BS — Brīvbode resolves the gap symbolically without changing acquisition.

4.2 MANAGING ON SITE #W83GJZ

  • #J3752R #SDRAJJ → infrastructure as material element (Shove via #AK6E4S

  • #4DUPXX (curatorial disagreement) → practice-as-performance contestation #VUVLX5

  • #FNC8R4 /#6C5JGN/#B3YNXY (situational rules) → directly engages footnote on Gram-Hanssen rules #79AM73 in Brīvbode informal rules operate through competence + meaning, not formal rules; also Tölg on care #VD2S8U

  • #4KPA9G /#XCCB38/#HNUDU6 (gender) → Lindsay et al/Organo #TFYF84 Miller #N2ZBHC Hobson #T7N8QV

  • #XR5PLN /#SQ2TGS/#SKSMZJ already cite Widlok — connect to practice theory: material arrangement shapes meaning options

  • #8BAVHR /#W7PS98/#YAE9S4 (resellers as forest sanitarians) → second-generation practice theory reflexivity (Askholm #U424KN #PXBZ7F

4.3 PLURAL MEANINGS #K2NJZZ

  • #4MH7S3 framing → Warde “consumption as moment in many practices” #7L43KL

  • #LX3MTQ /#BN4Q8D/#LCU322/#UGX7BR → consumption serving distinct host practices; Marta exemplifies competence-as-constitutive #7GWZ3Q

  • #33XZ4W /#Y6HMGJ stigma → Steward UBF5U3, Larsen HJXUZN/SHZ6RT (in corpus); generational shift = element recombination #9DUHV3

  • #GBR5SL energy/purgatory → Bohlin ZJUEY4; Kopytoff biography; Shove et al. on meaning migration #RPLH3Z

  • #RQW6FX /#MYBPDE (price-attachment) → genuine empirical contribution to Evans framework #KKUN6K appropriation/appreciation can be decoupled from monetary investment

  • #SGDXBS /#AT9W64 (trial/return) → extends Evans with a provisional acquisition mode

4.4 QUIET OR REFLECTED #GJEHTB

  • #57XB9K /#7CXSJ5/#WY7FSP → Smith & Jehlička quiet sustainability #3FUVVD Shove on routinisation #XF4WD9

  • #V9DG9E /#62253E (Agate/Laura) → Askholm/Welch second-gen reflexivity #U424KN #PXBZ7F Laura embodies value-action gap #3R87BS

  • Conclusion claim #4HG9B7 single site sustains practice through both quiet and articulated registers — this is a contribution.

HOUSEKEEPING: